IN THE NAME OF GOD, MOST GRACIOUS, EVER MERCIFUL
 

Are Women Second in Grade to Men?

 

Question

Does Islam look upon women as second grade in comparison to men?

Why is the testimony and inheritance of women half of men? It seems that all laws with regards to men and women are different with men given more benefits, rights and choice than women.

Even the language employed by the Quran with regards to men and women and to husband-wife relationship in particular seems to indicate that women are second grade or mere ownerships of men.

It seems that the role cut out for women in an Islamic society is very constricted and that women are not given freedom of movement and their choice options are limited.

I would appreciate a detailed discussion regarding the differences in the Islamic code when dealing with men and women.

Response

You wrote:

Does Islam look upon women as second grade in comparison to men?

I believe that today the world has become so biased in such issues of women that it is very difficult to do justice to Quran when understanding the rights of the two genders. Before we even look at the issue in Quran we already have some preconceived notions in our minds, for instance, giving birth to a child and raising them is considered inferior to running an office and earning money. This is despite the fact that only a woman has been bestowed with the quality of actually becoming pregnant and giving birth to a child and a man just cannot do it – God has not created man in such a fashion. It is indeed a terrible fallacy to suggest that giving birth to a child is any less important than any other job performed by a man, and those who believe it is inferior are actually being unjust by declaring one act inferior or superior over the other in order to convince one sex to drop their duties and start performing the duties of another.

In the bigger sphere of life, where a human through their death is going to meet their Lord, 'equality' is really the ability to succeed in the Hereafter. If a woman holds any lesser chance than a man only then it would constitute as not being equals to each other. However, that is not the case. God, in His supreme Wisdom, has promised absolute Justice to men and women alike. Therefore, in eyes of God, they are all equal.

No one can deny the fact that only a woman can give birth to a child. Men, on the other hand, may reveal their bravery in the battlefield but often are not fit to take care of a house or providing children with love and care that is much needed by them especially in the earlier phases of their lives. A few exceptions here and there will not change this overall structure and, based on this very nature on which God created men and women, He has prescribed spheres for both men and women which will create a successful family structure. The chances of success in the Hereafter for each soul are equal – all that is needed is the understanding of their responsibilities, performing them dutifully and striving for reward in the Hereafter. Quran says thus:

And do not wish for that in which God has favored one over the other. For men is a reward from that which they earn and for women is a reward from that which they earn. Ask God for His blessings. Lo! God is ever Knower of all things. (Quran 4:32)

Therefore, in response to your first question, it is certainly wrong to believe that women are treated as second grade to men. On the other hand, there are some areas in which woman has been favored over the man and Islam acknowledges this diversity in roles. Based on that Islam creates a family unit and bases the structure of the entire society on this institution of family in which different responsibilities are shared by both the partners. The question of women as second grade citizens should be posed to those who, through mere rhetoric, degrade the womanly duties performed by them, make them believe that feminine activities are inferior to men's and through this process make them do what men should be doing for women.

You asked:

Why is the testimony and inheritance of women half of men?

As far as the testimony of a woman is concerned, I believe it is a misunderstanding that it is half of men as a general rule. Consider the following case where the testimony of a woman is heavier than that of a man:

As for those who accuse their wives but have no witnesses except themselves; let the testimony of one of them be four testimonies, (swearing) by Allah that he is of those who speak the truth; And yet a fifth, invoking the curse of Allah on him if he is of those who lie. And it shall avert the punishment from her if she bear witness before Allah four times that the thing he said is indeed false, And a fifth (time) that the wrath of Allah be upon her if he speaks truth. (Quran 24:6-9)

Clearly, a woman's testimony has out rules that of a man in the case above. At many instances, Quran has mentioned the need for having witnesses at various places but at no place has the gender of the witnesses been mentioned. It is only in the following verse where the need to have two woman witnesses in place of one man witness has been identified:

O you who believe! When you contract a debt for a fixed term, record it in writing. Let a scribe record it in writing between you in (terms of) equity. No scribe should refuse to write as Allah hath taught him, so let him write, and let him who incurs the debt dictate, and let him observe his duty to Allah his Lord, and diminish naught thereof. But if he who owes the debt is of low understanding, or weak, or unable himself to dictate, then let the guardian of his interests dictate in (terms of) equity. And call to witness, from among your men, two witnesses. And if two men be not (at hand) then a man and two women, of such as you approve as witnesses, so that if the one errs (through forgetfulness) the other will remember. And the witnesses must not refuse when they are summoned. Be not averse to writing down (the contract) whether it be small or great, with (record of) the term thereof. ... (Quran 2:282)

Dr. Khalid Zaheer, while explaining the issue writes:

The reason why I believe that the verse 2:282 should be taken as a special case is that it is talking about a situation wherein a debt contract is to be written and witnesses are to be invited for the purpose giving evidence. They can be asked to give their evidence in case it is needed in the future. In such a situation the Qur'an has desired that two male witnesses should be produced for the purpose. The possibility of bringing in women in case men are available is not even mentioned. However, in the rare situation when two men are not available, the Qur'an says that a man and two women should be asked to give witnesses for the purpose, so that "if one of them forgets, the other should remind her". On the other hand, in the case of witnessing required to be done in verses 4:15 and 24:4 for cases of zina (fornication and adultery), since witnesses are not chosen like it is done by those who are to write a contract, but happen to be there at the time when crime is committed, there is no mention that only men should be selected for the purpose, or only in case if there are no men that women should be asked to come forward for the purpose. There is always a possibility that in case of crimes, there may only be women present to witness. Would their evidence be just rejected because of their gender?

To your question about inheritance, I have already explained that a man has been prescribed the responsibility of earning and providing for himself as well as the family. The woman has been not only been excused of such responsibilities rather her husband is made to provide for her. It is in keeping with these needs of men and women that the share of inheritance seems to have been made different. For the purposes of understanding – and in order to deal justly with the roles of men and women – one should look at it as if the inheritance is being divided between the daughter and the family of the son of the deceased. The son, required to provide for his needs as well as that of his family, has thus been prescribed twice the share as that of his sister by God Almighty.

You wrote:

Even the language employed by the Quran with regards to men and women and to husband-wife relationship in particular seems to indicate that women are second grade or mere ownerships of men.

I will request you to post me the specific verses which seem to give the impression you have stated in your question.

It seems that the role cut out for women in an Islamic society is very constricted and that women are not given freedoqm of movement and their choice options are limited. I would appreciate a detailed discussion regarding the differences in the Islamic code when dealing with men and women.

If by freedom of movement you mean the ability of woman to compliment her husband by helping him in various spheres of life, including sharing his hand in earning, but without transgressing any limits set by the Almighty, then Islam definitely does not constrict such movement rather it supports it. However if 'freedom of movement' is a phrase used to alter one's thoughts according to their wishes and desires, or according to the changing fashions of time and going forward with whatever movement takes air, without taking into account what the Almighty has ordained for us then definitely Islam not only constricts such a movement for women rather it does so for men as well. The reason is the simple fact that our aim here in this life is to achieve success in the Hereafter and if, because of the opinion of some people, that success is at the verge of being lost, it is indeed a great price to pay.